Atari Tries to Power-Up, Comes Off as Total n00b

Samantha Demetriou ⬥ 29 August

When dealing with domain names that contain a brand or trademark and are owned by third parties, one of the first things brand owners must consider before determining a course of action is how those domains are being used. Many times here at FairWinds, we see domains containing our clients’ brand names hosting pay-per-click (PPC) ads or being used for other obviously trademark-infringing purposes. In those instances, the process of recovering those domain names on behalf of our clients is usually fairly straightforward.

Total n00b

However, we also occasionally see these kinds of domain names being used in ways that cause serious headaches for brand owners, but technically might constitute fair use under copyright and trademark laws. One example is what we call gripe sites, like or While the content on these sites can wreak havoc on brand image, under the right circumstances it may constitute free speech and, as I mentioned, might be protected under copyright and trademark laws.
Similarly, fan sites can also constitute fair use. Fan sites that host no commercial content typically don’t cause brand owners quite as much grief, because their owners use them to sing the praises of a brand, product or service. One example is, a blog that describes itself as “An unofficial site, for any and all Starbucks enthusiasts everywhere!” The site is run by a woman named Melody Overton, who is a coffee aficionada and a Starbucks customer. She has she never worked for Starbucks, she just digs coffee.

Fan sites pop up around all kinds of brands and products. Unsurprisingly, the Internet is home to a rich ecosystem of fan sites dedicated to video games. There are even fan sites devoted to gaming systems that predate the Internet (and even the author of this post). That’s right, I’m looking at you, Atari.

While fans have a ton of love for the gaming company, Atari doesn’t seem to have a whole lot of love for the websites they build as platforms for their fandom.  According to gaming sites, Atari has been on the digital warpath, sending letters to the owners of fan sites demanding that they shut the sites down and turn over the domain names. One recipient and self-proclaimed “retro-gaming nut” Andrew Davie, who runs a site at, posted a farewell message on the site’s homepage where he pointed out, “The ’2600 platform has been near and dear to my heart for a long time.”

Here at FairWinds, we know better than almost anyone how important domain names and websites are in protecting brands and trademarks. But Atari’s aggressive “game-over” tactics may ultimately cost it some very loyal and long-time fans. 

Tags: Andrew Davie, Atari, brand, clients, copyright law, domain names, FairWinds, fan sites, gaming company, gripe sites, Internet, Melody Overton, PPC ads, Starbucks, third-party, trademark, trademark law

Latest Posts

Scroll to Top